Immigration judge

James F. III McCarthy

Community discussion · 0

Public EOIR asylum decision statistics

Status
active
Data source
EOIR Case Data

Grant rate

15.2%

19 / 125

Total decisions

125

Merits decision sample in current public statistics

Grant rate

15.2%

Grants: 19

Denial rate

84.8%

Denials: 106

Other relief rate

0.0%

Other relief: 0

Judge profile

This profile is summarized from public sources for background context only. It is not an ImmJudge evaluation.

Attorney General William Barr appointed James F. Mc Carthy III to begin supervisoryimmigration court duties and hearing cases in May 2019. He oversees the Cleveland Immigration Court. Judge Mc Carthy earned a Bachelor of Arts in 1974 from Xavier University and a Juris Doctor in 1977 from the Ohio State University College of Law. From 1995 until 2019, he was ashareholder in the law firm of Katz, Teller, Brant & Hild. From 1983 to 1995, he was an assistantcity solicitor and chief trial counsel for the city of Cincinnati. During that same time, he was ajudge advocate for the U. S. Navy in the following locations: Washington Navy Yard, Naval Legal Service Office; Norfolk, Virginia, Naval Legal Service Office; Newport, Rhode Island,Office of the Judge Advocate; Naval Air Station Pensacola, and Florida; Naval Air Station,Oceana, Virginia. From 1981 to 1983, he was with the law firm of Smith & Schnacke. From 1977 to 1981, he was an active duty judge advocate with the U.S. Navy at Commander Naval Surface Force, U.S. Atlantic Fleet and Naval Legal Service Office, Norfolk, Virginia. Judge Mc Carthy is a member of the Ohio Bar.

This summary is based on public material and may not reflect the latest assignment information.

Source: TRAC Judge Report · View original report

Outcome distribution

Grants19 / 125
Denials106 / 125
Other relief0 / 125

Community perspective

Community discussion

Read public experiences and process discussions related to James F. III McCarthy.

0 topics

You can start with these public topics

  • Share a public process or preparation experience
  • Discuss how to interpret public data
  • Ask a question without personal case details

Case details

0 rows

This table shows anonymized case details. It does not include applicant names, case numbers, A Numbers, or EOIR internal case IDs. Results are informational only, not legal advice, and cannot predict any individual case outcome.

Case Ratio

-

Distribution

Showing 0 of 0

View by applicant nationality

Review this judge's historical asylum outcomes for applicants from different nationalities.

Guatemala

Sufficient sample
View details

Total decisions

39

Grants

2

Denials

37

Grant rate: 5.1%Denial rate: 94.9%

Spain

Moderate sample
View details

Total decisions

27

Grants

5

Denials

22

Grant rate: 18.5%Denial rate: 81.5%

Honduras

Moderate sample
View details

Total decisions

10

Grants

0

Denials

10

Grant rate: 0.0%Denial rate: 100.0%

Mexico

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

9

Grants

0

Denials

9

Grant rate: 0.0%Denial rate: 100.0%

Kyrgyzstan

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

7

Grants

2

Denials

5

Grant rate: 28.6%Denial rate: 71.4%

India

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

3

Grants

1

Denials

2

Grant rate: 33.3%Denial rate: 66.7%

Brazil

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

2

Grants

0

Denials

2

Grant rate: 0.0%Denial rate: 100.0%

Central African Republic

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

2

Grants

1

Denials

1

Grant rate: 50.0%Denial rate: 50.0%

Ecuador

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

2

Grants

0

Denials

2

Grant rate: 0.0%Denial rate: 100.0%

Ivory Coast (Cote D'Ivoire)

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

2

Grants

2

Denials

0

Grant rate: 100.0%Denial rate: 0.0%

Mauritania

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

2

Grants

0

Denials

2

Grant rate: 0.0%Denial rate: 100.0%

South Africa

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

2

Grants

0

Denials

2

Grant rate: 0.0%Denial rate: 100.0%

Belarus

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

1

Grants

0

Denials

1

Grant rate: 0.0%Denial rate: 100.0%

Cameroon

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

1

Grants

1

Denials

0

Grant rate: 100.0%Denial rate: 0.0%

Estonia

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

1

Grants

0

Denials

1

Grant rate: 0.0%Denial rate: 100.0%

Gabon

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

1

Grants

0

Denials

1

Grant rate: 0.0%Denial rate: 100.0%

Ghana

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

1

Grants

1

Denials

0

Grant rate: 100.0%Denial rate: 0.0%

Guadeloupe

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

1

Grants

0

Denials

1

Grant rate: 0.0%Denial rate: 100.0%

Guinea

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

1

Grants

1

Denials

0

Grant rate: 100.0%Denial rate: 0.0%

Kenya

Small sample
View details

Total decisions

1

Grants

0

Denials

1

Grant rate: 0.0%Denial rate: 100.0%

These statistics come from public EOIR data. They reflect historical statistics only, are not legal advice, and cannot predict any individual case outcome.

Other judges at the same immigration court

Laura A. Baxter

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
47.2%
Denial Rate
52.8%
View details

Brandon M. Bolling

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
0.0%
Denial Rate
100.0%
View details

Alison M. Brown

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
29.7%
Denial Rate
70.3%
View details

Patrick Burke

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
7.0%
Denial Rate
93.0%
View details

D. William JR. Evans

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
15.1%
Denial Rate
84.9%
View details

Fred J. Guzzo

Status: active

Asylum Grant Rate
0.0%
Denial Rate
100.0%
View details
Disclaimer

This website is for general information only and is not legal advice.